CAN YOU CHALLENGE AN ADJUDICATION DETERMINATION WITHOUT FILING YOUR OWN REVIEW APPLICATION?

In China Communications Construction Co Ltd (Singapore Branch) v Zhao Yang Geotechnic Pte Ltd and another appeal [2026] SGHC(A) 27 (“China Communications”), the Appellate Division of the Singapore High Court held that a party which has not filed its own adjudication review application cannot use the other party’s application to challenge separate items in the adjudication determination (China Communications at [81]).

The decision clarifies an important distinction: responding to arguments about an item already under review is different from introducing another item for review. A party seeking to challenge a separate item must make its own application and comply with the statutory requirements (China Communications at [36]–[38] and [64]–[69]).

Background

China Communications engaged Zhao Yang as a subcontractor to carry out works at Changi Airport for a fixed lump sum of approximately S$22.7 million. Zhao Yang subsequently submitted a payment claim for approximately S$7.2 million, to which China Communications issued a nil payment response (China Communications at [10]–[11]).

The dispute concerned, among other things, whether omitted works should reduce the subcontract sum. China Communications maintained that it had validly varied the subcontract to omit works. Zhao Yang argued that the contract was for a lump sum and that it remained entitled to the full subcontract sum despite not having carried out some of the works (China Communications at [13]–[14]).

The adjudicator made deductions for works which had not been carried out and awarded Zhao Yang approximately S$3.54 million. China Communications applied for review of specified items decided against it (China Communications at [15]–[16]).

Zhao Yang did not file its own review application. Instead, it sought to challenge two further items in China Communications’ review. The review panel declined to consider those items and, after reviewing the items raised by China Communications, reduced the adjudicated amount to nil (China Communications at [18]–[20]).

The High Court held that the review panel should have considered Zhao Yang’s items and remitted the matter to the panel. Both parties appealed: China Communications challenged that finding, while Zhao Yang argued that the review determination should have been set aside altogether (China Communications at [22]–[24]).

Does a review application open up the whole determination?

The Court explained that a review adjudicator may review the entire adjudication determination where an application properly puts it in issue. However, that does not mean that a party which has not applied for review can introduce separate items beyond those identified in its opponent’s application (China Communications at [36]–[37]).

The earlier decision in Ang Cheng Guan Construction Pte Ltd v Corporate Residence Pte Ltd [2017] 3 SLR 988 had permitted a claimant to raise its own items through the respondent’s review application. The Court held that this decision was wrongly decided.

The statutory reference to a “review of the determination” identified what was being reviewed; it did not answer which items could be raised or who could raise them (China Communications at [2], [5] and [40]).

The review process is governed by statute. A party cannot obtain a right to challenge its own items merely because the other party has validly applied for review (China Communications at [41]–[43] and [71]–[72]).

Why must a party file its own application?

First, an adjudication review application must be lodged within seven days after service of the adjudication determination. An application made outside that period must be rejected. Allowing a party which missed that deadline to introduce its own items through its opponent’s application would effectively permit an out-of-time review (China Communications at [47] and [64]–[66]).

The Court also observed that an applicant which initially seeks review of specified items cannot add further items after the seven-day period has expired. Those additional items would, in substance, amount to an out-of-time application. This observation proceeded on the basis that the application identifies the items for review and is not open-ended (China Communications at [67]).

Second, a review applicant must comply with requirements concerning the application, supporting documents and fees. Where the respondent to the original adjudication seeks review, it must also pay the adjudicated amount to the authorised nominating body before applying. Permitting a party to raise its own items without an application would allow it to avoid those requirements (China Communications at [68]–[70]).

Third, allowing additional items to be introduced could undermine the mechanism for determining whether one or three review adjudicators should be appointed. That mechanism depends on the applicable monetary difference, and assumes that the items sought to be reviewed have been identified by the application deadline (China Communications at [73]–[77]).

Finally, a review applicant prepares its case by reference to the items raised within the prescribed period. It should not have to anticipate separate items which its opponent did not put forward for review in time (China Communications at [79]).

Can a party still argue about an item already under review?

The Court distinguished introducing a separate item from advancing arguments about an item already raised by the review applicant. Its decision should therefore not be read as requiring a party without its own application simply to adopt the original adjudicator’s reasoning (China Communications at [38]).

However, the Court left open whether a claimant without its own review application could go further and seek a higher amount for an item already under review. It expressed reservations about that possibility and considered legislative clarification desirable. The judgment does not establish an unrestricted right to obtain a better outcome without filing an application (China Communications at [54]–[61]).

Key takeaways

A party dissatisfied with separate items in an adjudication determination should identify those items and lodge its own review application within the statutory period, subject to the applicable requirements. It cannot rely on its opponent’s application to preserve challenges it has not itself made (China Communications at [64]–[69] and [81]).

The same care is required when preparing the application: filing in time does not leave the applicant free to add further items after the deadline. Parties should distinguish between arguments concerning items already under review and attempts to introduce separate items for determination (China Communications at [38], [67] and [79]).

This publication is not intended to be, nor should it be taken as, legal advice; it is not a substitute for specific legal advice for specific circumstances. You should not take, nor refrain from taking, actions based on this publication. Chancery Law Corporation is not responsible for, and does not accept any responsibility for, any loss or damage that may arise from any reliance based on this publication.

Shehzadul Haq